Haloes gone MAD: The Halo-Finder Comparison Project
Author
Knebe, Alexander; Knollmann, Steffen R.; Muldrew, Stuart I.; Pearce, Frazer R.; Aragon-Calvo, Miguel Angel; Ascasibar Sequeiros, Yago; Behroozi, Peter S.; Ceverino Rodríguez, Daniel; Colombi, Stephane; Diemand, Juerg; Dolag, Klaus; Falck, Bridget L.; Fasel, Patricia; Gardner, Jeff; Gottlöber, Stefan; Hsu, Chung Hsing; Iannuzzi, Francesca; Klypin, Anatoly; Lukić, Zarija; Maciejewski, Michal; Mcbride, Cameron; Neyrinck, Mark; Planelles, Susana; Potter, Doug; Quilis, Vicent; Rasera, Yann; Read, Justin I.; Ricker, Paul M.; Roy, Fabrice; Springel, Volker; Stadel, Joachim; Stinson, Greg; Sutter, Philip; Turchaninov, Victor; Tweed, Dylan; Yepes Alonso, Gustavo; Zemp, MarcelEntity
UAM. Departamento de Física TeóricaPublisher
Oxford University Press; RASDate
2011-08-01Citation
10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18858.x
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 415.3 (2011): 2293-2318
ISSN
0035-8711 (print); 1365-2966 (online)DOI
10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18858.xFunded by
We are greatly indebted to the ASTROSIM network of the European Science Foundation (Science Meeting 2910) for financially supporting the workshop ‘Haloes going MAD’ held in Miraflores de la Sierra near Madrid in 2010 May where all of this work was initiated.AK is supported by the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (MICINN) in Spain through the Ramón y Cajal programme as well as the grants AYA 2009-13875-C03-02, AYA2009- 12792-C03-03, CSD2009-00064 and CAM S2009/ESP-1496. SRK acknowledges the support by the MICINN under the Consolider-Ingenio, SyeC project CSD-2007-00050. SP and VQ have also been supported by the MICINN (grants AYA2010-21322-C03-01 and CONSOLIDER2007-00050) and the Generalitat Valenciana (grant PROMETEO-2009-103). MZ is supported by NSF grant AST-0708087. GY acknowledges financial support from MICINN (Spain) under project AYA 2009-13875-C03-02 and the ASTROMADRID project S2009/ESP-1496 financed by Comunidad de MadridProject
Comunidad de Madrid. S2009/ESP-1496/ ASTROMADRIDEditor's Version
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18858.xSubjects
Cosmology: miscellaneous; Cosmology: theory; Dark matter; Galaxies: evolution; Galaxies: haloes; Methods: numerical; FísicaNote
This article has been accepted for publication in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society © 2011 RAS © 2011 The authors Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society. All rights reservedRights
© 2011 The Authors; © 2011 RASAbstract
We present a detailed comparison of fundamental dark matter halo properties retrieved by a substantial number of different halo finders. These codes span a wide range of techniques including friends-of-friends, spherical-overdensity and phase-space-based algorithms. We further introduce a robust (and publicly available) suite of test scenarios that allow halo finder developers to compare the performance of their codes against those presented here. This set includes mock haloes containing various levels and distributions of substructure at a range of resolutions as well as a cosmological simulation of the large-scale structure of the universe. All the halo-finding codes tested could successfully recover the spatial location of our mock haloes. They further returned lists of particles (potentially) belonging to the object that led to coinciding values for the maximum of the circular velocity profile and the radius where it is reached. All the finders based in configuration space struggled to recover substructure that was located close to the centre of the host halo, and the radial dependence of the mass recovered varies from finder to finder. Those finders based in phase space could resolve central substructure although they found difficulties in accurately recovering its properties. Through a resolution study we found that most of the finders could not reliably recover substructure containing fewer than 30-40 particles. However, also here the phase-space finders excelled by resolving substructure down to 10-20 particles. By comparing the halo finders using a high-resolution cosmological volume, we found that they agree remarkably well on fundamental properties of astrophysical significance (e.g. mass, position, velocity and peak of the rotation curve). We further suggest to utilize the peak of the rotation curve, vmax, as a proxy for mass, given the arbitrariness in defining a proper halo edge
Files in this item
Google Scholar:Knebe, Alexander
-
Knollmann, Steffen R.
-
Muldrew, Stuart I.
-
Pearce, Frazer R.
-
Aragon-Calvo, Miguel Angel
-
Ascasibar Sequeiros, Yago
-
Behroozi, Peter S.
-
Ceverino Rodríguez, Daniel
-
Colombi, Stephane
-
Diemand, Juerg
-
Dolag, Klaus
-
Falck, Bridget L.
-
Fasel, Patricia
-
Gardner, Jeff
-
Gottlöber, Stefan
-
Hsu, Chung Hsing
-
Iannuzzi, Francesca
-
Klypin, Anatoly
-
Lukić, Zarija
-
Maciejewski, Michal
-
Mcbride, Cameron
-
Neyrinck, Mark
-
Planelles, Susana
-
Potter, Doug
-
Quilis, Vicent
-
Rasera, Yann
-
Read, Justin I.
-
Ricker, Paul M.
-
Roy, Fabrice
-
Springel, Volker
-
Stadel, Joachim
-
Stinson, Greg
-
Sutter, Philip
-
Turchaninov, Victor
-
Tweed, Dylan
-
Yepes Alonso, Gustavo
-
Zemp, Marcel
This item appears in the following Collection(s)
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Subhaloes going Notts: The subhalo-finder comparison project
Onions, Julian; Knebe, Alexander; Pearce, Frazer R.; Muldrew, Stuart I.; Lux, Hanni; Knollmann, Steffen R.; Ascasibar Sequeiros, Yago; Behroozi, Peter; Elahi, Pascal; Han, Jiaxin; MacIejewski, Michal; Merchán, Manuel E.; Neyrinck, Mark; Ruiz, Andrés N.; Sgró, Mario A.; Springel, Volker; Tweed, Dylan
2012-06-01 -
The AGORA high-resolution galaxy simulations comparison project
Abel, Tom; Agertz, Oscar; Bryan, Greg L.; Ceverino Rodríguez, Daniel; Christensen, Charlotte R.; Conroy, Charlie; Dekel, Avishai; Gnedin, Nickolay Yu; Goldbaum, Nathan J.; Hahn, Oliver; Hobbs, Alexander; Hopkins, Philip F.; Hummels, Cameron B.; Iannuzzi, Francesca; Klypin, Anatoly; Kravtsov, Andrey V.; Krumholz, Mark R.; Leitner, Samuel N.; Madau, Piero; Mayer, Lucio; Moody, Christopher E.; Nagamine, Kentaro; Norman, Michael L.; O'Shea, Brian W.; Pillepich, Annalisa; Primack, Joel R.; Read, Justin I.; Robertson, Brant E.; Rocha, Miguel; Rudd, Douglas H.; Shen, Sijing; Smith., Britton D.; Szalay, Alexander S.; Teyssier, Romain; Todoroki, Keita; Turk, Matthew J.; Wadsley, James W.; Wise, John H.; Zolotov, Adi; Kim, Ji-hoon; Guedes, Javiera; Keres, Dusan; Kuhlen, Michael; Onorbe, Jose; Quinn, Thomas; Thompson, Robert
2014-01-01 -
The first FERMI-LAT catalog of sources above 10 GeV
Ackermann, Markus; Ajello, Marco; Atwood, W. B.; Baldini, Luca; Ballet, Jean; Barbiellini, Guido; Bastieri, Denis; Belfiore, Andrea; Bellazzini, Ronaldo; Bernieri, Enrico; Bissaldi, Elisabetta; Bloom, Elliott D.; Bonamente, Emanuele; Brandt, T. J.; Bregeon, Johan; Brigida, Monica; Bruel, Philippe; Buehler, Rolf; Buson, Sara; Caliandro, G. Andrea; Cameron, Robert A.; Campana, Riccardo; Caraveo, Patrizia A.; Casandjian, Jean Marc; Cavazzuti, Elisabetta; Cecchi, Claudia; Charles, Eric; Chekhtman, Alexandre; Cheung, Chi C.; Chiang, James; Chiaro, G.; Ciprini, Stefano; Claus, Richard; Cohen-Tanugi, Johann; Cominsky, Lynn R.; Conrad, Jan; Cutini, Sara; D'Ammando, Filippo; De Angelis, Annalisa; De Palma, Francesco; Dermer, Charles D.; Desiante, R.; Digel, Seth W.; Di Venere, L.; Drlica-Wagner, Alex; Favuzzi, C.; Fegan, Stuart J.; Ferrara, Elizabeth C.; Focke, Warren B.; Franckowiak, Anna; Funk, Stefan; Gargano, Fabio; Gasparrini, Dario; Germani, Stefano; Giglietto, Nicola; Giommi, Paolo; Giordano, Francesco; Giroletti, Marcello; Gómez-Vargas, Germán A.; Grenier, Isabelle A.; Guiriec, Sylvain; Hadasch, Daniela; Hanabata, Yoshitaka; Harding, Alice K.; Hayashida, Masaaki; Hays, Elizabeth; Hill, Adam B.; Horan, Deirdre; Hughes, R. E.; Jogler, Tobias; Jóhannesson, Gudlaugur; Johnson, Arne S.; Johnson, Tony J.; Johnson, W. Neil; Kamae, Tuneyoshi; Kataoka, Jun; Kawano, Takafumi; Knödlseder, Jürgen; Lande, Joshua; Larsson, Stefan; Latronico, Luca; Lemoine-Goumard, Marianne; Longo, Francesco; Loparco, Francesco; Lott, Benoît; Lovellette, Michael N.; Lubrano, Pasquale; Massaro, Enrico; Mazziotta, Mario Nicola; McEnery, Julie E.; Méhault, Jérémie; Michelson, Peter F.; Mizuno, Tsunefumi; Moiseev, Alexander A.; Monzani, Maria Elena; Morselli, Aldo; Moskalenko, Igor V.; Murgia, Simona; Nuss, Eric; Ohsugi, Takashi; Okumura, Akira; Orienti, Monica; Ormes, Jonathan F.; Paneque, David; Perkins, Jeremy S.; Pesce-Rollins, Melissa; Piron, Frédéric; Pivato, G.; Porter, Troy A.; Rainò, Silvia; Razzano, Massimiliano; Reimer, Anita; Reimer, Olaf L.; Ritz, Steven; Romani, Roger W.; Roth, Markus; Saz Parkinson, Pablo M.; Schulz, Anneli; Sgrò, Carmelo; Siskind, Eric J.; Smith, David A.; Spandre, Gloria; Stawarz., Łukasz; Strong, Andrew W.; Suson, Daniel J.; Takahashi, Hiromitsu; Thayer, John Gregg; Thayer, J. B.; Thompson, David J.; Tibaldo, Luigi; Tinivella, M.; Torres, Diego F.; Tosti, Gino; Troja, Eleonora; Uchiyama, Yasunobu; Usher, T. L.; Vasileiou, Vlasios; Vianello, Giacomo; Vítale, Vincenzo; Winer, Brian L.; Wood, Kent S.; Allafort, A.; Bechtol, Keith; Burnett, T. H.; Drell, P. S.; Fusco, P.; Gehrels, Neil; Godfrey, Gary; Hewitt, John; Kuss, Michael; Mayer, Markus; Nemmen, Rodrigo; Spinelli, P.; Vandenbroucke, Justin; Werner, Marcel; Wood, Murray; Chaves, Ryan C.G.; Reposeur, Th.; Fortin, Pascal
2013-11-14